A novated lease has been arranged between a Leasing Company and their customer. The Leasing Company placed an order with a Dealer and arranges delivery details for their Customer.
The Dealer has the vehicle in stock under a floor plan arrangement with a floor plan financier, who has registered a security interest in the vehicle (the dealer is the Grantor and the financier is the Secured Party).
The Dealer delivers the vehicle to the novated lease customer. The Lease Company registers a PMSI against the vehicle. The Dealer is required to pay out the floor plan financier 14 days after delivery. The Leasing Company is proposing to pay the Dealer 28 days after delivery and to take title to the vehicle.
Holding Redlich Say….
1. Should the dealer register a PMSI and, if so, when and how?
If the Dealer is delivering the vehicle to the Leasing Company before the Dealer receives payment of the full purchase price, ideally the Dealer should register a PMSI over the vehicle on or before delivery. In order to register a PMSI the Dealer needs to ensure that its contract of sale with the Leasing Company enables the dealer to register a PMSI and that this is permitted under its floor plan financing arrangements. If no PMSI is registered, the Dealer will be an unsecured creditor of the Leasing Company.
2. How does the PPS Act affect the grey area in the diagram? If 3 parties have perfected interests, who takes priority?
If all three parties have perfected PMSIs in the vehicle then generally the time of registration will determine priority (unless other priority arrangements have been agreed). This will mean that the perfected PMSI registered first in time will typically have first priority.
However, a perfected PMSI will have priority over a security interest which is not a PMSI even if that security interest is registered earlier in time.
3. Does the Dealer need to pay out their financier on or before delivery before the Dealer can register an interest in the vehicle?
Whether or not it will be necessary for a Dealer to have first paid out its financier and arranged for the removal of the financier’s security interest over the vehicle before it can deliver the vehicle or register a PMSI will depend on the terms of the financing arrangements with the financier and the contract with the Leasing Company.
It is likely though that the Leasing Company will insist on receiving clear title to the vehicle on delivery and that the financier will refuse to remove its registered security interest over the vehicle unless it is paid out. This means it will be preferable to schedule the transaction so that payment by the Leasing Company, removal of the financier’s interest in the vehicle and delivery of the vehicle occur contemporaneously.
If the Dealer is in a position to pay out the financier in order to obtain a release of the financier’s interest over the vehicle prior to receiving payment from the Leasing Company, it would then be prudent for the Dealer to ensure the contract for the sale of the vehicle to the Leasing Company enables the dealer to register a PMSI over the vehicle on or before delivery which is only to be removed once the Dealer receives payment of the purchase price in full. The Dealer’s PMSI would need to be registered prior to any PMSI the Leasing Company may register or there would need to be an agreement with the Leasing Company regarding priority of the 2 PMSIs.
Click here to view a diagram of this case scenario